![]() |
The lamps have gone out all over America. |
By Isaiah Thomas
Board of Editors
This publication was established 255 years ago to advocate for the independence of the then British colonies and the establishment of a democratic Constitutional republic that would rule according to laws enacted with the consent of the governed and dedicated to the proposition that government existed to protect the rights and advance the interests of the governed.
Six years later, on July 4, 1776, the Spy's efforts were crowned with success by the signature of the Declaration of Independence, which established the United States of America as a democratic republic.
At some point in the latter half of its 249th year, that government died.
On this July 4, 2025, we pause to pronounce and mourn its passing.
How do we know it has died? Consider:
– Just last week, the six bent Republican Supreme Court Justices decided that Article III courts lacked the power to prevent the Executive Branch from repealing Constitutional amendments on its own say so. In particular, the infant children of certain types of immigrants will now be denied citizenship in clear contravention of the Fourteenth Amendment unless they themselves crawl into court and sue on the own behalf. Trump v. CASA, No. 24A884 (June 27, 2025).
As Professor Kate Shaw explained in a rare worthwhile essay in New York Times Opinion:
In Trump v. CASA, the Supreme Court could have definitively decided that Mr. Trump’s executive order purporting to end birthright citizenship is flagrantly unconstitutional and may not be enforced. Instead, the court announced that it alone can decide such matters on a nationwide basis — and that it would not do so here. ...
Both the general tenor of the opinion and these instructions — to rapidly reconsider these cases in the context of an entirely new standard announced in an opinion that is far from clear — evinced a remarkable lack of respect for lower courts. And the decision comes at a time when district court judges have done more than any other constitutional players to maintain core constitutional protections. These are the same district judges who are facing unprecedented attacks online, threats to their safety and impeachment resolutions.
As Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson noted in her dissent: “Perhaps the degradation of our rule-of-law regime would happen anyway. But this court’s complicity in the creation of a culture of disdain for lower courts, their rulings and the law (as they interpret it) will surely hasten the downfall of our governing institutions, enabling our collective demise.”
– As part of its program to terrorize, torture, and eventually deport aliens with pending or no status (i.e. awaiting decisions on timely filed asylum petitions), the Executive Branch has arrogated to itself the right and power to:
- arrest and detain legal permanent residents of the United States for expressing opinions disagreeable to the President
- summarily deport in the unreviewable discretion of the Secretary of State any alien he determines to be an “enemy” and to not just deport them but deliver them variously to a foreign concentration camp or a third country war zone regardless of whether the alien will face torture in either hellhole
- concoct criminal prosecutions against sitting members of Congress for seeking to exercise their legal right to inspect immigration detention facilities
- tackle and beat U.S. Senators for attempting to ask a Cabinet Secretary a question as part of their Article I duty to oversee the U.S. Government
- beat and arrest not just persons suspected without probable cause for lacking immigration status satisfactory to them but also American citizens for attempting to protect those individuals and their and their own constitutional rights:
- and commence illegal denaturalization proceedings against US citizens for failing to agree with the President
But the unconstitutional actions of an out-of-control Presidency go far beyond torturing immigrants and beating dissenters. In the past six months, the Executive has unconstitutionally
- terminated federal agencies established by Congress and cut off their funding, resulting in the likely deaths of millions of starving children and families in famine-ravaged lands
- cut off legally appropriated and awarded funding to research universities to force them to submit to the political will and bigoted views of the current President
- imposed tariffs without the consent of the Congress as required by Article I
- illegally deployed US military forces into American cities to harass and oppress the populace
- allied with the Russian aggressor in Ukraine in defiance of Congressional action
- threatened to conquer by military force all or part of nations allied with the United States
- pardoned 1,500 convicted insurrectionists and then hired some of them to work in, wait for it, the Justice Department
- purged the Justice Department of career prosecutors who acted in accordance with the law but not the whim of the Executive; and
- demanded bribes from media corporations to punish them for speaking truth and from others to line his own pockets in multiple scams
None of these actions can be reconciled with the American Constitution, the rule of law, or the separation of powers.
What happened?
The causes of the collapse of the American Republic are many and deep rooted, although they can all be traced to the contradictions of its founding: the tension between establishing the dignity and equality of all human beings and the reality of granting excessive power to white slavers and racists to perpetuate their cruel oligarchy.
In the 21st century, several different strands of white power were woven together into a rope strong enough to pull down the structure of American government. A Republican-dominated Supreme Court first overturned the voters' verdict in the 2000 election, preserving Republican domination of the Court for a generation. Later it lawlessly voided a key provision of the Voting Rights Act, paving the way for suppression of minority and Democratic votes.
That same Republican-packed Supreme Court in turn cemented the domination of Republicans by sanctioning unlimited plutocratic dark money in politics under the guise of “free speech.” It furthered Republican gerrymandering of Congressional seats for blatant political advantage, thereby permitting partisan politicians to stifle the popular will.
As a result of these decisions, the Republican Party in the Congress became increasingly dominated by corrupt reactionaries dependent on the favor of a depraved President to remain in office. Both these developments destroyed the separation of powers and key checks against Executive Branch tyranny.
Today for example the House approved a cruel unpopular bill to starve and sicken the poor and grant huge tax cuts to billionaires. The margin was 218 to 214. That's two votes. The Republican gerrymander of swing-state North Carolina in 2024 gave the Republican three new seats, or more than the margin of victory the Republicans enjoyed today.
![]() |
Devoted Fox News watcher |
Soon the Republican Texas legislature is planning to redistrict Texas Congressional seats in the absence of any new Census data to unseat Democrats they don't like, like Jasmine Crockett. A similar effort in 2003 generated five more seats for Texas Republicans.
A second factor has been the transformation of the media into emasculated irrelevance (like the networks and major newspapers) or nonstop disinformation volcanoes whose lies have sunk into and eaten the brains of millions of white Americans:
...there are many, many Americans who blame Fox News for changes in their loved ones, and many people out there who feel as though their friends and family members have been lost to a 24/7 stream of right-wing propaganda.
....Any salesperson or con artist will tell you that you can’t incept a thought in a mark’s mind out of nowhere. You have to find the hook that’s already there — fear, or desire — and exploit it. When it comes to exacerbating and honing the anxieties of aging Americans you can’t do much better (or worse) than race and immigration.
Because the truth is, Fox News didn’t invent racism, and many of our family members would’ve believed in it on their own. This may have been the hardest thing I learned from the stories I heard: Fox didn’t necessarily change anyone’s mind, so much as it seems to have supercharged and weaponized a politics that was otherwise easy for white Americans to overlook in their loved ones.
Which leads us to the overarching cause of the death of the American republic: perpetuation of white plutocratic power by whatever means necessary. This has been a battle since the founding of our Republic, according to Prof. Heather Cox Richardson:
In the United States today, a political minority has used the mechanics of government to take power and is now using that power to impose its will on the majority. The pattern is exactly that of the elite southern enslavers who in the 1850s first took over the Democratic Party and then, through it, captured the Senate, the Supreme Court, and the White House and tried to take over the country.
The story of the 1850s centered around the determination of southern planters to preserve the institution of human enslavement underpinning the economy that had made them rich and powerful, and today we tend to focus on the racial dominance at the heart of that system.
![]() |
It took the French five tries to get it right |
Even as we face the reality that the American First Republic (or Second if you regard Reconstruction as the establishment of a new and better regime) has passed, the response cannot be either despair or acquiescence.
France after all is now on its Fifth Republic and when we were there two weeks ago, it seemed pretty jolly. If the French can re-establish a stable democratic Republic and still have time to hang out in cafés, we can do the same.
While the forces that destroyed the American Republic remain powerful, they are by no means invulnerable. In any event, the future has a funny way of surprising us. In this century alone we have endured a mass terror attack, an economic meltdown, a pandemic, and puppy killer Kristi Noem. We are likely to be confronted by similarly consequential evens in the future: another pandemic, another economic collapse, war, perhaps involving nuclear weapons, and another animal murderer. Each crisis creates an opportunity.
But that may or may not happen in the lifetimes of anyone writing or reading these words.
In the meantime it is for us the living to record the demise of a promising experiment in democratic government and to assign blame for its death where it is due: on white people.