By Hebraic Affairs Editor A. Cahan with Spy Detroit Bureau Chief Betty McGlown in West Bloomfield, Michigan.
It could have been so much worse. A deranged anti-semite tried to drive a truck full of explosives into Temple Israel, one of the largest synagogues in Detroit or for that matter anywhere. Thanks to the heroic efforts of well-trained security guards, he was foiled and eventually killed himself. The hundred plus children on the campus were safe.
There's no doubt that these are very scary times for American Jews. Attacks on their houses of worship, ever since the Tree of Life attack in Pittsburgh that killed 11 back in 2018, have become a part of American Jewish life. And it's taking a toll on them, or, to be more candid, us.
According to The New York Times,
Jewish institutions now spend $765 million annually on security, according to an estimate last year by the Jewish Federations of North America. A typical Jewish organization spends 14 percent of its annual budget on security, the organization estimates.
The president and chief executive of the Jewish Federations, Eric Fingerhut, called this a “Jewish tax” in a recent speech calling for increased federal funding for security, among other measures.
$765,000,000 is a lot of money that could otherwise go for Jewish stuff, like education, religion, or tikkun olam. But the toll isn't just financial:
“I think the Jewish community had just about had it,” Rabbi Steven Abraham, who leads Beth El Synagogue, a Conservative congregation in Omaha, Neb., said on Thursday afternoon. “There’s a level of PTSD with the heightened awareness.”
Is there anything that can done to help American Jews feel safer? Don't worry – we'll get to that.
First, we'll sample some of the reaction, other than generalized fear, grief, and anxiety.
The usual neocon suspects aren't wasting any time weaponizing these synagogue attacks against their usual suspects, which includes anyone, including any Jew, who doesn't buy into their neocon Likud fantasies.
David “Axis of Evil” Frum argued in The Atlantic (natch) that the Michigan attack shows that antisemitic violence has now become “mainstream,” whatever that means. And therefore of course all sentient Jews owe Bibi Netanyahu their blind support, no many how many civilian lives he destroys for no adequate reason.
The idea that American Jews are floating in a leaky lifeboat in a vast and unfathomable sea of antisemitism is central to their fantasy. Unfortunately for ol' Axis of Evil, it turns out that the terrorist responsible for the Michigan attack was not just another mainstream antisemite.
Rather he had a very specific grudge. His brothers and the brother's children had just been killed in a no-doubt very discriminating attack on supposed Hezbollah positions in Southern Lebanon. The brothers may have in fact been members of Hezbollah. No word on the sympathies of his kids.
Now the Israeli bombing doesn't justify antisemitic violence against synagogues. But the particular grudge this perpetrator had suggests that antisemitism is not some vast ineffable phenomenon. This terrorist had a very particular motive and grudge. There's no reasonable basis to connect his deranged reaction to his loss to every or indeed any Muslim or ethnic minority in the United States or to cite it as an example of how antisemitic violence has become the norm.
Unfortunately that doesn't mean that American Jews can ignore the possibility of violent attacks on their houses of worship.
These kind of threats seem like something that the U.S. Department of Homeland Security should be concerned about and willing to assist Jewish organizations in preparing for.
Not in the Mad King's America.
Synagogues seeking grants to protect Jews from antisemitic terror from the DHS have been told that DHS will provide the money only if the synagogue's members betray every Jewish value and embrace the Mad King's bigotry, hatred, and racism:
Beginning in 2025, the Department of Homeland Security attached sweeping ideological conditions to new security grants. Recipients of new awards must cooperate with Immigration and Customs Enforcement operations, and must also agree not to “operate any programs that advance or promote DEI, DEIA, or discriminatory equity ideology.” They additionally must not run any aid program which “benefits illegal immigrants or incentivizes illegal immigration.”
When asked to clarify what those conditions mean in practice — whether a synagogue that declares itself a sanctuary for refugees would be disqualified, or whether a congregation offering programming for Jews of color or LGBTQ+ Jews would run afoul of the anti-DEI clause — the federal government’s answer has been months of contradictory guidance and confusion.
As a result synagogues are having to tax their own members so they don't betray fundamental Jewish values:
Closer to home:
$200,000 is real money, even for a large temple in affluent Newton, Mass. But if DHS is going to condition protecting Jews from terror on surrendering Jewish values, what choice did it have?
The imposition of this Sophie's Choice on synagogues by the hateful demented Mad King regime and its stooges (who until last week were spending DHS money, not on protecting Jews, but on Mile-High Club membership drives on government jets with private bedrooms) deserves condemnation from everyone.
We'll let you know whether the reactionary gasbags who inveigh against antisemitism as a way to smear anyone who doesn't agree with their Likud values like Frum, Bretbug, or even apostate Jew St. David Brooks, speak out against this evil.
In the meantime, we'll be preparing for Passover when Jews sit around a big table, eat inedible crap like ground up fish in aspic, and read from one of their well-known texts, the Haggadah, CCAR ed. at 56:
When a stranger resides with you in your land,you shall not wrong him....You shall love him as yourself for you were strangers in the Lad of Egypt.
Because American Jews hold fast to these timeless truths, the Mad King's regime is putting them in mortal jeopardy.
If you're looking for examples of antisemitism to condemn, you could start there, Bretbug.




























